Malaysia court ruling on unequal JMB maintenance fees exposes gaps in strata law, say managers
A Federal Court ruling that nullified unequal maintenance fees during a joint management body (JMB) period has highlighted gaps in Malaysia's Strata Management Act 2013. Industry figures say the decision was narrower than some headlines suggested and call for clearer rules on multi-rate charges, esp
A recent Federal Court ruling on unequal maintenance fees has exposed lingering gaps in Malaysia's Strata Management Act 2013 (Act 757), according to building managers and industry observers.
On 8 Sept 2026, a three-member Federal Court bench unanimously dismissed an application by Hatten Square's management corporation (MC) in Melaka for leave to appeal a Court of Appeal decision. The lower court had ruled that differential maintenance fees imposed during the joint management body (JMB) period were null and void. Costs of RM50,000 were awarded.
Richard Chan, director of RCMC Sdn Bhd and former president of the Malaysia Shopping Malls Association, says the ruling was narrower than some press coverage suggested. 'The ruling was in reference to arbitrarily imposing different maintenance charges to owners during the JMB period. There is actually a provision for MCs to impose multi-rates under the current SMA,' he tells EdgeProp.
Datin Harwinder Kaur, managing partner at AJ Ariffin, Yeo & Harpal, concurs. 'The Hatten Square dispute concerned differential charges during the JMB period. The Federal Court refused leave to appeal, leaving the Court of Appeal's decision standing. Section 25(3) requires JMB charges to be proportionate to allocated share units.' She notes that MCs have a separate power under section 60(3)(b) to impose different rates for parcels used for significantly different purposes.
Chan says the current SMA offers no multi-rate provisions for JMBs, leaving developments stuck under a JMB for years if strata titles have not been issued. 'In many previous cases, courts have ruled in favour of MCs when there were conflicts arising from charging multi-rate charges, because these were viewed through the lens of the merits of individual cases. In the recent case, there was an absence of any multi-rate provision for JMBs,' he says.
Harwinder says she would support allowing provisions for multi-rate charges by the JMB in the SMA update. 'Mixed developments may have materially different maintenance needs across residential, retail and hotel components. However, different rates must reflect justified costs and account for existing share-unit weightings.' She adds that transparent budgets and protection against cost-shifting are essential, but any reform must come through legislation.
The Housing and Local Government Ministry (KPKT) announced in June 2026 it would review the SMA with input from the National Housing Department (JPN) and industry stakeholders. Harwinder says differential charging for maintenance fees is among the issues identified for review. In a parliamentary reply dated 22 Jul 2025, KPKT acknowledged the different powers of JMBs and MCs and said it was examining whether to align those powers and ensure fair charging methods. A September 2026 update confirmed that maintenance charging mechanisms remained under consideration.
The Building Management Association of Malaysia (BMAM) has welcomed KPKT's review and the proposed introduction of the Building Managers Act (BMA) under the National Housing Policy 2026–2035. BMAM president Tan Sri Teo Chiang Kok says the BMA would give KPKT unified authority over the entire building ecosystem, eliminating fragmented oversight. He says the act must preserve the democratic structure of owner self-management while ensuring access to a regulated pool of competent practitioners.