Melaka Court of Appeal reserves ruling on Sacred Heart Canossian Convent land title dispute
Malaysia's Court of Appeal on 20 Nov 2026 reserved its decision on an appeal by the Canossian Sisters and the Portuguese Mission seeking recognition of their claimed interest in Lot 6, Banda Hilir, Melaka. The three-member bench fixed 3 Dec for case management. The dispute concerns land housing a sc
PETALING JAYA (Nov 20): The Court of Appeal on Friday (Nov 20) reserved its decision on an appeal by the Canossian Sisters and the Portuguese Mission seeking recognition of their claimed interest in the land occupied by the Sacred Heart Canossian Convent in Melaka and a replacement title for the property. The three-member bench, led by Datuk Azizul Azmi Adnan, said it needed more time to deliver its decision and fixed Dec 3 for case management. Datuk Faizah Jamaluddin and Datuk Aliza Sulaiman also sat on the bench, according to a report by The Edge Malaysia.
The appeal concerns Lot 6 in Banda Hilir, which houses a school, a chapel and the sisters’ residence. In its August coverage, The Edge Malaysia reported that the appellants claimed ownership of the land and said the convent had occupied it since 1905.
The appellants are the Mother Superior of the Daughters of Charity of the Canossian Institute (Malaya) and the agent of the Commission for the Administration of the Estates of the Portuguese Missions in China and Singapore. They brought judicial review proceedings against Melaka’s director of land titles, director of land and mines, and registrar of titles.
The Melaka High Court dismissed their application in 2025 after finding that they had failed to establish a pre-existing legal or beneficial interest in Lot 6, The Edge Malaysia reported. Chinese-language daily Oriental Daily News reported in July 2025 that the court found the land belonged to the state and the buildings belonged to the convent.
At Friday’s hearing, the appellants’ lawyers argued that the land authorities had previously acknowledged that historical records identified the Portuguese Convent as the owner of Lot 6. They disputed the authorities’ interpretation that the entry referred to the site’s use and argued that a replacement title should be issued even though the original Dutch title deed was missing, The Edge Malaysia reported. Melaka state legal adviser Datuk Khairul Azreem Mamat maintained that the appellants had to establish a pre-existing interest in the land, according to the report.
FMT reported on Aug 6 that the Court of Appeal had admitted 1936 correspondence concerning Lot 6 and the then Melaka municipality, preserved at the National Archives of Malaysia. The court found that the appellants had made reasonable efforts to locate the records and that the correspondence could bear on the ownership dispute. It declined to admit a 1934 municipal map because it did not help determine ownership. At the July hearing on the fresh-evidence application, the appellants’ lawyer Joy Wilson Appukuttan told the court that a chapel building application submitted on behalf of the Portuguese Mission identified the mission as the owner of both the land and the building, FMT reported.
The appellants began seeking registration of their claimed interest in 2014 under the National Land Code (Penang and Malacca Titles) Act 1963, according to The Edge Malaysia’s account of Friday’s hearing. The registrar asked for the original Dutch title deed, which the appellants said had been lost during the Japanese occupation. In March 2022, the land authorities told the appellants’ lawyers that they lacked authority to register ownership of Lot 6 and suggested taking the matter to court, the publication reported.